Driver distraction from cell phone use and potential for self-limiting behavior

Abstract

This project consists of three parts. The first is a review of the literature on driver distraction that primarily focuses on cell phone use. The second two parts involve analysis of an existing field operational test (FOT) database to examine: 1) self-limiting behavior on the part of drivers who use cell phones, and 2) eye glance patterns for drivers involved in cell phone conversations and visual-manual tasks (e.g., texting) as compared to no-task baseline driving. The literature review discusses the apparent contradiction between results of case-crossover and simulator studies that show increases in instantaneous risk due to talking on a cell phone and results of crash-data analyses that show no substantial increase in crashes associated with increases in cell phone use in vehicles. The first data analysis shows some evidence of self-limiting behavior in cell phone conversations. Drivers initiate calls when on slower roads and at slower speeds, often when stopped. However, they call more at night, which is a higher-risk time to drive. The second analysis showed that eye glances when talking on the phone are fixated on the road for longer periods of time than in baseline driving. In contrast, on-road eye glances when engaged in a visual-manual (VM) task are short and numerous. Eye glances on and off the road are about equal in length, and the average total off-road gaze time for a five-second interval is about 2.8 secs, or 57% of the time. Average off-road gaze time out of five seconds in baseline driving is about 0.8 sec, or 16% of the time. Results show the differences in distraction mechanism between cell-phone conversations and texting. Ramifications for potential interventions are discussed.