Indonesian sluicing and verb phrase ellipsis: Description and explanation in a minimalist framework.
Fortin, Catherine Rose
2007
Abstract
This dissertation investigates two elliptical phenomena, sluicing and verb phrase ellipsis (VPE), in Indonesian. This dissertation is equally concerned with description and formal analysis, and provides the first in-depth description and generative analysis of both Indonesian sluicing and VPE. First, I show that Indonesian displays auxiliary-stranding VPE, similar to English. I demonstrate that this ellipsis (i) targets the <italic> v</italic>P and (ii) is distinct from other elliptical phenomena including null complement anaphora, stripping, comparatives, and individual null constituents. Second, I show Indonesian sluicing to be typologically unusual, failing to obey Merchant's (2001) Preposition Stranding Generalization. This generalization, which posits a correlation between preposition stranding in <italic>wh</italic>-questions and preposition omission in sluicing, has been argued to support the PF-Deletion approach (e.g. Ross 1969), under which sluices are formed with <italic>wh </italic>-movement identically to non-elliptical <italic>wh</italic>-questions. I show that, under PF-Deletion, Indonesian sluices involve <italic>wh</italic>-movement, arguing (i) the sluices are not elliptical <italic>wh</italic>-clefts, but are elliptical <italic>wh</italic>-questions and (ii) Indonesian <italic> wh</italic>-questions involve <italic>wh</italic>-movement. Indonesian sluicing thus presents a challenge to PF-Deletion. Thirdly, sluiced <italic>wh</italic>-phrases crosslinguistically are known to not be subject to island constraints. Under PF-Deletion, islands are realized as properties of PF representations, and violations are repaired through deletion of the island from the representation. I argue this view of islands is untenable within Minimalism, showing it is impossible to formulate Subjacency as a constraint on representations. Consequently, the lack of island effects under sluicing cannot be handled by PF-Deletion. I contend a theory of ellipsis must be compatible with the alternative view of islands: the Minimal Link Condition, as part of the definition of Move (Chomsky 2004), prevents all Subjacency-violating movements. Finally, I propose a Minimalist 'LF-Copying' analysis, compatible with Subjacency as an inviolable constraint, to account for Indonesian sluicing. The <italic>wh</italic>-phrase is generated in [Spec, CP] and later associated with a TP-internal variable, following 'sidewards' movement of the antecedent TP into the sluiced clause. In Chung, Ladusaw, and McCloskey's original (1995) proposal, this association obtains via a semantic coindexing operation, Merger. I propose Merger be reformulated as long-distance Agree (Chomsky 2004) between C<super>0</super>/<italic>wh</italic>-phrase and its correlate in the antecedent TP.Subjects
Description Explanation Framework Indonesian Minimalist Sluicing Syntax Verb Phrase Ellipsis
Types
Thesis
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
Remediation of Harmful Language
The University of Michigan Library aims to describe library materials in a way that respects the people and communities who create, use, and are represented in our collections. Report harmful or offensive language in catalog records, finding aids, or elsewhere in our collections anonymously through our metadata feedback form. More information at Remediation of Harmful Language.
Accessibility
If you are unable to use this file in its current format, please select the Contact Us link and we can modify it to make it more accessible to you.