Toward the usable recognition of individual benefits and costs in regulatory analysis and governance
dc.contributor.author | Cranor, Carl F. | |
dc.contributor.author | Finkel, Adam M. | |
dc.date.accessioned | 2018-03-07T18:25:25Z | |
dc.date.available | 2019-05-13T14:45:25Z | en |
dc.date.issued | 2018-03 | |
dc.identifier.citation | Cranor, Carl F.; Finkel, Adam M. (2018). "Toward the usable recognition of individual benefits and costs in regulatory analysis and governance." Regulation & Governance 12(1): 131-149. | |
dc.identifier.issn | 1748-5983 | |
dc.identifier.issn | 1748-5991 | |
dc.identifier.uri | https://hdl.handle.net/2027.42/142513 | |
dc.description.abstract | Regulatory agencies in the United States and Europe have well‐deserved reputations for fixating on the total benefits and costs of proposed and final regulatory actions, without doing any more than anecdotally mentioning the subpopulations and individuals who may bear disproportionate costs or reap disproportionate benefits. This is especially true on the “cost” side of the cost–benefit ledger, where analysts exert little effort to even inform decisionmakers and the public that the costs of regulations might be distributed either regressively or progressively. Many scholars and advocates have observed that regulation can increase the efficiency of market outcomes, but caution about its untoward (or suboptimal) effects on equity. Here, we argue that without considering distributional information about costs and benefits, regulatory policies in fact can also cause violence to notions of efficiency, for two reasons: (i) society cannot hope to approach Pareto‐efficient outcomes without identifying those who must lose so that others can gain more; and (ii) because the harm experienced by involuntary risks and by imposed regulatory costs is likely non‐linear in its magnitude (at the individual level), efficiency is, in fact, a strong function of the shape of the distribution of these effects. This article reviews evidence about the distribution of regulatory costs and benefits, describes how agencies fail to incorporate readily available distributional information, and sketches a vision for how they could analyze costs and benefits to promote more efficient regulatory choices and outcomes. | |
dc.publisher | OUP | |
dc.publisher | Wiley Periodicals, Inc. | |
dc.subject.other | interindividual variability | |
dc.subject.other | utility functions | |
dc.subject.other | valuation | |
dc.subject.other | efficiency | |
dc.subject.other | cost–benefit analysis | |
dc.title | Toward the usable recognition of individual benefits and costs in regulatory analysis and governance | |
dc.type | Article | en_US |
dc.rights.robots | IndexNoFollow | |
dc.subject.hlbsecondlevel | Political Science | |
dc.subject.hlbtoplevel | Government, Politics and Law | |
dc.description.peerreviewed | Peer Reviewed | |
dc.description.bitstreamurl | https://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/142513/1/rego12128_am.pdf | |
dc.description.bitstreamurl | https://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/142513/2/rego12128.pdf | |
dc.identifier.doi | 10.1111/rego.12128 | |
dc.identifier.source | Regulation & Governance | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Rawls J ( 1971 ) A Theory of Justice. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Renda A, Schrefler L, Luchetta G, Zavatta R ( 2013 ) Assessing the Costs and Benefits of Regulation. Study for the European Commission. Secretariat General, CEPS, Brussels. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Robinson LA, Hammitt JK, Zeckhauser R ( 2016 ) Attention to distribution in U.S. regulatory analyses. Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 10 ( 2 ), 308 – 328. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Salin V, Finkel AM ( 2013 ) Variability in Costs to Comply with Regulations: An Application To Food Safety. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: https://sites.google.com/a/adamfinkel.com/nsfprojectoutputs/home | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Shapiro S ( 2011 ) Defragmenting the Regulatory Process. Risk Analysis 31, 893 – 901. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Shapiro S, Goodwin J ( 2013 ) Distorting the Interests of Small Business: How the Small Business Administration Office of Advocacy’s Politicization of Small Business Concerns Undermines Public Health and Safety. Center for Progressive Reform, White Paper #1302, January 2013, Washington, DC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Stern J, Wiener JB ( 2006 ) Precaution Against Terrorism, KSG Working Paper No. RWP06‐019. Harvard Kennedy School of Government, Cambridge, MA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Sunstein CR ( 2002 ) Risk and Reason: Safety, Law, and the Environment. CUP, Cambridge, UK. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Sunstein, CR ( 2012 ) The Stunning Triumph of Cost‐Benefit Analysis. BloombergView 12 Sep. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: https://www.bloomberg.com/view/articles/2012-09-12/the-stunning-triumph-of-cost-benefit-analysis | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Thompson KM, Rabouw RF, Cooke RM ( 2001 ) The Risk of Groundling Fatalities from Unintentional Airline Crashes. Risk Analysis 21, 1025 – 37. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | US EPA (US Environmental Protection Agency) ( 2006 ) EPA’s Action Development Process: Guide to Considering Children’s Health When Developing EPA Actions: Implementing Executive Order 13045 and EPA’s Policy on Evaluating Health Risks to Children. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2014-05/documents/epa_adp_guide_childrenhealth.pdf | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | US EPA (US Environmental Protection Agency) ( 2010 ) 40 CFR Parts 50, 53, and 58: Primary National Ambient Air Quality Standard for Sufur Dioxide; Final Rule. Federal Register 75 ( 119 ), 35520 – 35602. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://www3.epa.gov/ttn/naaqs/standards/so2/fr/20100622.pdf | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | US EPA (US Environmental Protection Agency) ( 2011 ) Exposure Factors Handbook. EPA/600/R‐090/052 F. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: https://www.epa.gov/expobox/exposure-factors-handbook-2011-edition | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | US EPA (US Environmental Protection Agency) ( 2014 ) Plan EJ 2014: Legal Tools. Office of General Council, US EPA, Washington DC. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: https://www.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2015‐02/documents/ej‐legal‐tools.pdf | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | US EPA (US Environmental Protection Agency) ( 2016 ) Regulatory Flexibility for Small Entities [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://www.epa.gov/rfa/overview.html | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Vesell ES ( 1985 ) Implications for Risk Assessment of Host Factors Causing Large Pharmacokinetic Variations. Toxicology and Industrial Health 1 ( 4 ), 135 – 152. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Viscusi WK ( 2007 ) The Flawed Hedonic Damages Measure of Compensation for Wrongful Death and Personal Injury. Journal of Forensic Economics 20 ( 2 ), 113 – 135. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Viscusi WK ( 2012 ) What’s to know? Puzzles in the Literature on the Value of Statistical Life. Journal of Economic Surveys 26, 763 – 768. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | West WF ( 2015 ) The Administrative Presidency as Reactive Oversight: Implications for Positive and Normative Theory. Public Administration Review 75, 523 – 533. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Wildavsky A ( 1979 ) The Politics of the Budgetary Process. Little, Brown, Boston, MA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Williams R, Broughel J ( 2015 ) Principles for Analyzing Distribution in Regulatory Impact Analysis. Mercatus Center, George Mason University, Arlington, VA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Woodruff TJ, Zeise L, Axelrad DA, Guyton KZ, Janssen S, Miller M et al. ( 2008 ) Meeting Report: Moving Upstream‐Evaluating Adverse Upstream End Points for Improved Risk Assessment and Decision‐making. Environmental Health Perspectives 116, 1568 – 1575. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 1990 ) A Simple Formula for Calculating the “Mass Density” of a Lognormally Distributed Characteristic: Applications to Risk Analysis. Risk Analysis 10, 291 – 301. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 1997 ) Not to Decide is to Decide: Ignoring Susceptibility is not “Good Science”. Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology 4, 219 – 227. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 2008 ) Protecting People in Spite of—or Thanks to—the “Veil of Ignorance”. In: Sharp RR, Marchant GE, Grodsky JA (eds) Genomics and Environmental Regulation: Science, Ethics, and Law, pp. 290 – 342. Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Adler MD ( 2012 ) Well‐being and fair distribution: Beyond cost‐benefit analysis. OUP, New York. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Adler MD ( 2013 ) Cost‐Benefit Analysis and Distributional Weights: An Overview. Duke Environmental and Energy Economics Working Paper Series, EE 13‐04, August 2013. Nicholas Institute for Environmental Policy Solutions/Duke University Energy Initiative, Durham, NC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Anthes E ( 2010 ) “ Hey Would‐Be Daddies, How You Take Care of Yourself Plays into the Health of Your Future Children.” [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://www.alternet.org/story/149200/hey_would‐be_daddies2C_how_you_take_care_of_yourself_plays_into_the_health_of_your_future_children | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Ashford NA ( 2005 ) Incorporating Science, Technology, Fairness, and Accountability in Environmental, Health, and Safety Decisions. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 11, 85 – 96. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Barlow BK, Cory‐Slechta DA, Richfield EK, Thiruchelvam M ( 2007 ) The Gestational Environment and Parkinson’s Disease: Evidence for Neurodevelopmental Origins of a Neurodegenerative Disorder. Reproductive Toxicology 23, 457 – 470. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Bernoulli D ( 1738 ) Exposition of a New Theory on the Measurement of Risk (translated and reprinted in Econometrica 22 ( January 1954 )), 23 – 36. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Bronsteen J, Buccafusco C, Masur JS ( 2013 ) Well‐Being Analysis vs. Cost‐Benefit Analysis. Duke Law Journal 62, 1603 – 1689. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Carpenter D, Moss DA (eds) ( 2014 ) Preventing Regulatory Capture: Special Interest Influence and How to Limit It. CUP, Cambridge, MA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Coglianese C, Finkel AM, Carrigan C (eds) ( 2014 ) Does Regulation Kill Jobs? University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Copeland CW ( 2008 ) Congressional Influence on Rulemaking and Regulation through Appropriations Restrictions. Congressional Research Service Report for Congress, Updated August 5, 2008, RL34354. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Crain NV & Crain WM ( 2010 ) The Impact of Regulatory Costs on Small Firms, U.S. Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy SBAHQ‐08‐M‐0466, Easton, PA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Cranor CF ( 1997 ) Eggshell Skulls and Loss of Hair from Fright: Some Moral and Legal Principles that Protect Susceptible Subpopulations. Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology 4, 239 – 245. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Cranor CF ( 2011 ) Legally Poisoned: How the Law Puts Us at Risk from Toxicants. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Dietert RR, Piepenbrink MS ( 2006 ) Perinatal Immunotoxicity: Why Adult Exposure Assessment Fails to Predict Risk. Environmental Health Perspectives 114, 477 – 483. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Dietert RR, Zelikoff JT ( 2010 ) Identifying Patterns of Immune‐related Disease: Use in Disease Prevention and Management. World Journal of Pediatrics 6, 111 – 118. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Earthjustice ( 2014 ) Defending Fenceline Communities from Oil Refinery Pollution. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://earthjustice.org/our_work/cases/2014/defending‐fenceline‐communities‐from‐oil‐refinery‐pollution | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | European Commission ( 2015a ) Better Regulation Guidelines. European Commission, Strasbourg, France. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | European Commission ( 2015b ) Better Regulation Toolbox—Tool #19: The “SMETEST.” [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://ec.europa.eu/smart‐regulation/guidelines/tool_19_en.htm | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Executive Order of the President No. 12898 ( 1994 ) Federal Register Vol. 59 No. 32, February 16, 1994. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://www.archives.gov/federal‐register/executive‐orders/pdf/12898.pdf | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Fennema H, van Assen M ( 1998 ) Measuring the Utility of Losses by Means of the Tradeoff Method. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 17, 277 – 295. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 2011 ) The Regulatory Flexibility Act Improvements Hearing: Testimony of Adam M Finkel before the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Small Business, June 15, 2011. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://smallbusiness.house.gov/uploadedfiles/finkel_testimony.pdf | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 2013 ) Protecting the Cancer Susceptibility Curve. Environmental Health Perspectives 121, A238. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 2014a ) The Cost of Nothing Trumps the Value of Everything: The Failure of Regulatory Economics to Keep Pace with Improvements in Quantitative Risk Analysis. Michigan Journal of Environmental and Administrative Law 4, 91 – 156. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 2014b ) EPA Underestimates, Oversimplifies, Miscommunicates, and Mismanages Cancer Risks by Ignoring Human Susceptibility. Risk Analysis 34, 1785 – 1794. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkel AM ( 2016 ) “I Thought You’d Never Ask: Structuring Regulatory Decisions to Stimulate Demand for Better Science and Economics.” Manuscript in review. European Journal of Risk Regulation. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Finkelstein A, Luttmer EFP, Notowidigdo MJ ( 2009 ) Approaches to Estimating the Health State Dependence of the Utility Function. American Economic Review: Papers and Proceedings 99, 116 – 121. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Fisher E ( 2007 ) Opening Pandora’s Box: Contextualising the Precautionary Principle in the European Union. Oxford Legal Studies Research Paper, No. 2/2007. University of Oxford, Oxford. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Fox M ( 2015 ) Five Things to Know about the EPA’s New Rule for Oil Refineries. Earthjustice, Nov 6. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://earthjustice.org/blog/2015‐november/5‐things‐to‐know‐about‐the‐epa‐s‐new‐rule‐for‐oil‐refineries | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Frankfurt HG ( 2015 ) On Inequality. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Friedman R ( 1981 ) Sensitive Populations and Environmental Standards: An Issue Report. Conservation Foundation, Washington, DC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Fullerton D ( 2011 ) Six Distributional Effects of Environmental Policy. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 16703. NBER, Cambridge, MA. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Fullerton D & West S ( 2003 ) Public Finance Solutions to Vehicle Emissions Problems in California. Berkeley Electronic Press, Berkeley. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://services.bepress.com/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1000&context=fullertonwest | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Ginsburg DH, Menashi S ( 2010 ) Nondelegation and the Unitary Executive. University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law 12, 251 – 276. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Goldstein BD, Demak M, Northridge M, Wartenburg D ( 1992 ) Risk to Groundlings of Death Due to Airplane Accidents: A Risk Communication Tool. Risk Analysis 12, 339 – 41. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Grandjean P, Landrigan P ( 2006 ) Developmental Neurotoxicity of Industrial Chemicals. Lancet 368, 2167 – 2178. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Hahn RW, Dudley PM ( 2007 ) How Well Does the U.S. Government Do Benefit–Cost Analysis? Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 1, 192 – 211. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Hammitt JK, Treich N ( 2007 ) Statistical vs. Identified Lives in Benefit‐Cost Analysis. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 35, 45 – 66. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Harrington W, Safirova E, Coleman C, Houde S & Finkel AM ( 2014 ) Distributional Consequences of Public Policies: An Example from the Management of Urban Vehicular Travel. Resources for the Future Discussion Paper RFF‐DP‐14‐04. RFF, Washington, DC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Hattis D ( 1997 ) Human Variability in Susceptibility: How Big, How Often, for What Responses to What Agents? Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology 4, 195 – 208. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Hattis D, Barlow K ( 1996 ) Human Interindividual Variability in Cancer Risks: Technical and Management Challenges. Human and Ecological Risk Assessment 2, 194 – 220. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Hattis D, Goble R, Chu M ( 2005 ) Age‐Related Differences in Susceptibility to Carcinogenesis II: Approaches for Application and Uncertainty Analyses for Individual Genetically Acting Carcinogens. Environmental Health Perspectives 113, 509 – 516. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Health Assembly of the American Thoracic Society, Committee of the Environmental and Occupational Health Assembly ( 1996 ) Health Effects of Outdoor Air Pollution, 3 – 50. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Her Majesty’s Treasury ( 2011 ) The Green Book: Appraisal and Evaluation in Central Government, London. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Hershleifer J ( 1980 ) Price Theory and Applications, 2nd edn. Prentice‐Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Institute of Medicine ( 2006 ) Valuing Health for Regulatory Cost‐Effectiveness Analysis. National Academies Press, Washington, DC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Kysar DA ( 2010 ) Regulating from Nowhere: Environmental Law and the Search for Objectivity. Yale University Press, New Haven. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Lehner P ( 2015 ) After 15 Years, EPA Finally Moves to Ban Brain‐damaging Pesticide Chlorpyrifos. Earthjustice, Dec 7. [Last accessed 15 July 2016.] Available from URL: http://earthjustice.org/blog/2015‐december/after‐15‐years‐epa‐finally‐moves‐to‐ban‐brain‐damaging‐pesticide‐chlorpyrifos | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Linder SH, Marko D, Sexton K ( 2008 ) Cumulative Cancer Risk from Air Pollution in Houston: Disparities in Risk Burden and Social Disadvantage. Environmental Science & Technology 42, 4312 – 4322. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | McCubbins MD, Noll RG, Weingast BR ( 1987 ) Administrative Procedures as Instruments of Political Control. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 3, 243 – 277. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | NRC (National Research Council) ( 1994 ) Science and Judgment in Risk Assessment. National Academies Press, Washington, DC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | NRC (National Research Council) ( 2009 ) Science and Decisions: Advancing Risk Assessment. National Academies Press, Washington, DC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | OSHA (Occupational Safety & Health Administration) ( 1997 ) Occupational Exposure to Methylene Chloride: Final rule. Federal Register 62, 1494 – 1619. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | OSHA (Occupational Safety & Health Administration) ( 2006 ) Occupational Exposure to Hexavalent Chromium: Final rule. Federal Register 71, 10100 – 10385. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | OSHA (Occupational Safety & Health Administration) ( 2016 ) Occupational Exposure to Respirable Crystalline Silica: Final Rule. Federal Register 81, 16286 – 16890. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Oswald AJ ( 2008 ) On the Curvature of the Reporting Function from Objective Reality to Subjective Feelings. Economic Letters 100, 369 – 372. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Pizer WA, Kopp R ( 2003 ) Calculating the Costs of Environmental Regulation. Resources for the Future, Discussion Paper 03‐06. RFF, Washington, DC. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Wagner WE ( 2000 ) The Triumph of Technology‐based Standards. University of Illinois Law Review 2000 ( 1 ), 83 – 113. | |
dc.identifier.citedreference | Renda A ( 2011 ) Law and Economics in the RIA World. Erasmus University, Rotterdam. | |
dc.owningcollname | Interdisciplinary and Peer-Reviewed |
Files in this item
Remediation of Harmful Language
The University of Michigan Library aims to describe library materials in a way that respects the people and communities who create, use, and are represented in our collections. Report harmful or offensive language in catalog records, finding aids, or elsewhere in our collections anonymously through our metadata feedback form. More information at Remediation of Harmful Language.
Accessibility
If you are unable to use this file in its current format, please select the Contact Us link and we can modify it to make it more accessible to you.