A User-aware Intelligent Refactoring for Discrete and Continuous Software Integration

Abstract

Successful software products evolve through a process of continual change. However, this process may weaken the design of the software and make it unnecessarily complex, leading to significantly reduced productivity and increased fault-proneness. Refactoring improves the software design while preserving overall functionality and behavior, and is an important technique in managing the growing complexity of software systems. Most of the existing work on software refactoring uses either an entirely manual or a fully automated approach. Manual refactoring is time-consuming, error-prone and unsuitable for large-scale, radical refactoring. Furthermore, fully automated refactoring yields a static list of refactorings which, when applied, leads to a new and often hard to comprehend design. In addition, it is challenging to merge these refactorings with other changes performed in parallel by developers. In this thesis, we propose a refactoring recommendation approach that dynamically adapts and interactively suggests refactorings to developers and takes their feedback into consideration. Our approach uses Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm (NSGAII) to find a set of good refactoring solutions that improve software quality while minimizing the deviation from the initial design. These refactoring solutions are then analyzed to extract interesting common features between them such as the frequently occurring refactorings in the best non-dominated solutions. We combined our interactive approach and unsupervised learning to reduce the developer’s interaction effort when refactoring a system. The unsupervised learning algorithm clusters the different trade-off solutions, called the Pareto front, to guide the developers in selecting their region of interests and reduce the number of refactoring options to explore. To reduce the interaction effort, we propose an approach to convert multi-objective search into a mono-objective one after interacting with the developer to identify a good refactoring solution based on their preferences. Since developers may want to focus on specific code locations, the ”Decision Space” is also important. Therefore, our interactive approach enables developers to pinpoint their preference simultaneously in the objective (quality metrics) and decision (code location) spaces. Due to an urgent need for refactoring tools that can support continuous integration and some recent development processes such as DevOps that are based on rapid releases, we propose, for the first time, an intelligent software refactoring bot, called RefBot. Our bot continuously monitors the software repository and find the best sequence of refactorings to fix the quality issues in Continous Integration/Continous Development (CI/CD) environments as a set of pull-requests generated after mining previous code changes to understand the profile of developers. We quantitatively and qualitatively evaluated the performance and effectiveness of our proposed approaches via a set of studies conducted with experienced developers who used our tools on both open source and industry projects.