Grief, Health, and Medicalization
Kelley, Alice Elizabeth
2024
Abstract
This dissertation is comprised of three chapters: Chapter 1 intervenes in debates about the medicalization of grief, focusing on the recent addition of a grief-specific disorder – Prolonged Grief Disorder (PGD) – to the DSM. Opponents of medicalization have been primarily concerned with potential negative looping effects – ways that classificatory processes like medicalization (treating something as a disorder) contribute to harmful social practices or distortions of a person’s self-conception. Contrastingly, I call attention to unappreciated beneficial looping effects that might be achieved by medicalizing (some) experiences of grief. Alongside this, I highlight that the concerns about negative looping effects rest on the philosophically significant and conceptually optional assumption that “normal” parts of human experience should not be medicalized. Consequently, I argue that rather than removing PGD from the DSM, the better path forward is to help grievers reconceive the role of diagnostic categories by moving away from a background understanding of health conditions as pathologies. Chapter 2 develops an account of healthy grief as a constructive dialectical process – rather than either a state or a healing process aimed at “recovery”. On the account I develop, it is not a condition of healthy grief that it dissipates over time. Endless grief can be both appropriate and compatible with flourishing. In this respect, my account departs from various well-known accounts of grief (of which perhaps the most illustrious is Freud's in Mourning and Melancholia). In addition, my account sets itself apart from others in that it includes respect-for-the-lost-one as a central component of the dialectics of grieving. This move is pivotal, as it sets the stage for a picture of grieving on which grief is a positive component of living a flourishing life. In addition, the account I develop here has implications for our understanding of health, medicalization, and disorder; most notably it reinforces the case against conceptions of health that reduce health and human flourishing to merely the absence of pathology, dysfunction, or disease. Chapter 3 extends the account of grief developed in the previous chapter to other forms of loss, with a particular focus on anticipatory grief. Considering multiple forms of loss elucidates two notable features of grief (i) object plenitude: in grief, there is never just one object of loss; the objects stand in intimate and overlapping relations with each other such that there are not always boundaries between them and (ii) object generation: the process of grieving partially determines which things are seen as losses. Having elucidated these features, I show how my account sheds light on some of the different ways that we can become “stuck” in our experiences of grief. Finally, I consider the practical (clinical, social, and interpersonal) upshots of my account.Deep Blue DOI
Subjects
Grief Health Philosophy of Medicine Medicalization
Types
Thesis
Metadata
Show full item recordCollections
Remediation of Harmful Language
The University of Michigan Library aims to describe library materials in a way that respects the people and communities who create, use, and are represented in our collections. Report harmful or offensive language in catalog records, finding aids, or elsewhere in our collections anonymously through our metadata feedback form. More information at Remediation of Harmful Language.
Accessibility
If you are unable to use this file in its current format, please select the Contact Us link and we can modify it to make it more accessible to you.