Index Catalog // Deep Blue Data

Need language around using Deep Blue Data as a repository for your NIH data sharing plan? See Data Sharing Boilerplate

Start Over

Filtering by: Creator Song, Jean Creator Townsend, Whitney A Keyword Open Peer Review

Analyzing Reviewer Responses to Systematic Review Search Methodology through Open Peer Review

Creator:

Townsend, Whitney A, MacEachern, Mark P, and Song, Jean

Description:

We conducted a search through BioMed Central's 54 medicine and public health journals that provide OPR documentation in order to identify systematic review papers published in 2017. For each article we determined if OPR data, reviewer and author comments, were accessible. If so, we assessed the search methodology and reporting quality of the search process with a grading rubric based on PRISMA and PRESS standards, and then mined peer reviewer comments for references to the search methodology.

Keyword:

Systematic Reviews, Peer Review, Open Peer Review, Methodology, Research Methods, and Reporting

Discipline:

Health Sciences